Polygraph

On AirNo. 1Election fraud

3Noncitizens are voting in large numbers

That noncitizens, including people in the country illegally, are voting in U.S. elections in large numbers. The Justice Department says it has charged 48 noncitizens with election crimes.

← All eight claims

Carried by 422 shows from Jul 27 to Oct 28. Repeated against rebutted:

Listeners

3,785,152repeated
3,813,952rebutted

1.0× as many rebutting it. Plus 13,863,047 reporting or discussing it without taking a side.

Hours

44 hrrepeated
21 hrrebutted

2.1× as many repeating it. Plus 28 hr reporting or discussing it without taking a side.

Segments

354repeated
181rebutted

2.0× as many repeating it. Plus 282 reporting or discussing it without taking a side.

Day by day

Day by day

354 segments repeated it. 181 rebutted it.

Each column is one day. Segments that repeated the claim stack up from the line, segments that rebutted it hang below; the numbered marks are the dated events.

Sep 4 The Justice Department charges five people in Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Wisconsin over noncitizen voting.

In the week from that day, 12 segments repeated it and 4 rebutted it; in the week before, 26 and 15. Votebeat

Sep 30 A federal grand jury in Minneapolis indicts 10 noncitizens on illegal-voting charges.

In the week from that day, 22 segments repeated it and 15 rebutted it; in the week before, 29 and 18. MPR News

Oct 21 A federal judge halts the administration’s noncitizen-voter investigations in nine states, Nevada and California among them.

In the week from that day, 58 segments repeated it and 40 rebutted it; in the week before, 43 and 23. AJC / AP

Oct 26 The Justice Department says it has charged 48 noncitizens with election crimes.

In the week from that day, 40 segments repeated it and 13 rebutted it; in the week before, 59 and 47. Spectrum News

Day by day

Segments a day

Repeated above the line, rebutted below. Jul 27 – Oct 28

Segments a day

Repeated above the line, rebutted below. Jul 27 – Oct 28

Segments a day

Repeated above the line, rebutted below. Jul 27 – Oct 28

Segments a day

Repeated above the line, rebutted below. Jul 27 – Oct 28

Segments a day

Repeated above the line, rebutted below. Jul 27 – Oct 28

↑ Repeated
↓ Rebutted

Source: Polygraph read of podcast segments; segments, Particle

  1. 1Sep 4. The Justice Department charges five people in Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Wisconsin over noncitizen voting. Votebeat
  2. 2Sep 30. A federal grand jury in Minneapolis indicts 10 noncitizens on illegal-voting charges. MPR News
  3. 3Oct 21. A federal judge halts the administration’s noncitizen-voter investigations in nine states, Nevada and California among them. AJC / AP
  4. 4Oct 26. The Justice Department says it has charged 48 noncitizens with election crimes. Spectrum News

Who carried it

Every show that repeated it, above the line, and every show that rebutted it, below, placed by the show’s size: its estimated listeners an episode. A bigger dot is more segments; the three biggest carriers on each side are named.

↑ Repeated it↓ Rebutted it

Show size: estimated listeners an episode →

Show size, estimated listeners an episode:Under 1,0001,000 to 100,000100,000 and up

Repeated

Shows71%27%
Listeners27%72%

Rebutted

Shows58%39%
Listeners24%76%

Repeated · 181 shows

50% of the 3,785,152 listeners from the biggest, The Dan Bongino Show; 69% from the top three.

Rebutted · 134 shows

35% of the 3,813,952 listeners from the biggest, NPR News Now; 71% from the top three.

About these numbers

Each segment’s side is read from its podcast-index entry, its title and summary, not the audio. Segments that report or discuss the claim without taking a side are counted apart. Hours on air is the length of the segments as the index cuts them: time on the subject, not seconds spent saying the claim.

Listeners is an estimate of each episode’s audience, modelled from the show’s followers and summed over the episodes that carried a side, each episode once. Treat it as an order of magnitude. Lean is the show’s rating. Source: Particle.

Our Weekly Newsletter

The Readout

The week's most-shared posts, checked. What they claimed, how they argued, and what held up.

Unsubscribe any time. See our privacy policy.