Russia had socialist institutions including the commune, the artel, and the monastery brotherhood of the Holy Cross.
Posted by The Pete Quiñones Show, Checked
- Sources
- 4 support2 context
- Said
- 1 time·
- Confidence
- 40%
The Pete Quiñones ShowOct 1, 2026
Sources confirm that Russian peasant communes and artels existed as collective associations, but none addresses whether they were 'socialist institutions', and no source mentions a 'monastery brotherhood of the Holy Cross'. The claim also drops the post's qualifier 'in a broad definition of the term'.
What we found
Supports. Multiple sources describe the Russian artel and the peasant commune as collective, co-operative forms of organization that existed in Russia.[2][3][4][5]
Context. Marx's 1893 letter to Danielson discusses the commune and artel as possible bases for socialist development, but it frames this as a hypothetical rather than an established fact about socialist institutions.[6]
Context. The 'socialist' label is interpretive: scholarship presents the artel and commune as romanticized by socialists, not as documented socialist institutions in their own right.[3]
Context. No source mentions a 'monastery brotherhood of the Holy Cross'. The only brotherhood listed in the voluntary-societies source is an 'Orthodox Christian Brotherhood', which is not the same body.[1]
Sources
6 sources: 1 primary, 5 not rated
- 1Voluntary Societies and Mobilizationpages.uoregon.edu · primary source · cited for: context
- 2Intentional community - Wikipediaen.wikipedia.org · not rated · cited for: supports
- 3Russia as the land of communism in the nineteenth century ?journals.openedition.org · not rated · cited for: supports, context
- 4[PDF] Russian artel revisited through the lens of the New Institutional ...scispace.com · not rated · cited for: supports
- 5V On Social Relations in Russiadhspriory.org · not rated · cited for: supports
- 6Letters: Marx-Engels Correspondence 1893 - Marxists Internet Archivemarxists.org · not rated · cited for: context
Where this claim was made
Said in 1 published post
- The Pete Quiñones Show · “Russia, of all places, had functioning, in a broad definition of the term, socialist institution: the commune itself, the artel, and the monastery brotherhood of the Holy Cross.”Post →
Related claims
- Tsarist Russia had labor cooperatives known as the artel system.True
- There was no systematic prison system or labor camp system in the Czarist era.False
- By the start of World War I, 95% of the Russian peasantry owned their own land.False
- Russia experienced growth in industry, money, and population in the second half of the 19th century.True
- The Red Cross mission in Russia was a cover for British and American Wall Street interests.True