Polygraph

Should Memorial Vandals Get Stiffer Penalties?

The Kuhner Report, Checked

Polygraph score
80Holds up15 claims checked
Details
What it claims
4 false17 can’t tell19 true
How it argues
Nothing found
How it persuades
Nothing found
What it’s built on
Nothing found
Sources
2 rated low
The Kuhner ReportOct 26, 2026
View on Podcast ↗
The Kuhner Report cover art
The Kuhner ReportShould Memorial Vandals Get Stiffer Penalties?Whole episode, 39:55
Episode page →
40 claims

What it claims

Claims

  1. 1TrueThe National Symphony Orchestra is performing Tchaikovsky's The Nutcracker and Prokofiev's Cinderella in November.The NSO's 2026-27 schedule lists a November concert program of Tchaikovsky's The Nutcracker and Prokofiev's Cinderella, with dates of Nov. 20-22, 2026, so the claim was true as of 2026-10-26. The sources describe the works as the Nutcracker Suite and Cinderella Suite, which is a standard reading of the same program.8 sources →

    ▶ 0:00

  2. 2TrueJorge Federico Osorio is performing Mozart's Piano Concerto Number 21 with the National Symphony Orchestra.Multiple sources published in September and October 2026 list Jorge Federico Osorio as the soloist in Mozart's Piano Concerto No. 21 on the National Symphony Orchestra's Nutcracker & Cinderella concerts in November 2026. The claim describes a scheduled performance as of the 2026-08-21 posting date, and the post's own wording matches it faithfully.5 sources →

    ▶ 0:16

  3. 3TrueThe National Symphony Orchestra is performing Tchaikovsky's The Nutcracker and Prokofiev's Cinderella at Rachel Schlesinger Hall on November 20, 2026.Multiple sources, including the NSO-related WETA schedule and ticket listings from October, show The Nutcracker & Cinderella on November 20 at Rachel M. Schlesinger Concert Hall in Alexandria, consistent with the claim as of 2026-10-26. One OrchestraFinder listing places the November 20 concert at the Kennedy Center, and the claim's extraction is faithful to the post's own program and venue wording.7 sources →

    ▶ 23:03

  4. 4TrueXfinity Shield provides protection against online threats and risky sites for every device.Sources published before the 2026-10-26 post show that Xfinity CyberSecure, which the post calls Xfinity Cyber Secure and which is included in Xfinity Shield, provides always-on protection against malware, online threats and risky sites for connected devices. The post's 'every device' wording matches the FAQ's 'every connected device', though coverage applies to customers with an eligible Xfinity Gateway.4 sources →

    ▶ 10:30

  5. 5TrueXfinity Shield offers a Wi-Fi price guarantee for five years.Xfinity's own site and a review site both describe a five-year price guarantee on select Xfinity internet plans, and the guarantee is promoted alongside Xfinity Shield. The claim drops the 'select plans only' qualifier and calls it a Wi-Fi price, but the sources describe an internet plan price, so the core assertion holds on a standard reading. Sources dated before 2026-10-07 are absent, so the state on that date is inferred from later pages.4 sources →

    ▶ 1:13

  6. 6Can’t tellDonald Trump is currently in his third year of his second term as president.The sources show Trump's second term began January 20, 2025, which makes October 26, 2026 the second year of that term, not the third; the post itself said he was "almost going into his third year," so the extracted claim that he is "currently in his third year" departs from the passage. Because the extraction adds a present-tense assertion the post did not make, the verdict is unverifiable rather than false, though the sources would contradict the claim as worded.6 sources →

    ▶ 2:44

  7. 7Can’t tellThe speaker has voted for Donald Trump three times.The claim is the post author's own statement about their voting history, and no independent source confirms or refutes it. The only closely matching source is a 2026 transcript of the same podcast host repeating the same statement, which is the claimant's own words and cannot corroborate it; the other sources concern different people or unrelated Trump statements.2 sources →

    ▶ 4:35

  8. 8TrueDonald Trump served two terms as President of the United States.Multiple tier-1 sources confirm Trump served a first term (2017-2021) and began a second, non-consecutive term on January 20, 2025, so the claim that he served two terms is supported. The second term was still in progress as of the 2026 reporting, which the claim does not address, and one low-credibility page wrongly lists a single term.6 sources →

    ▶ 4:46

  9. 9MixedJohn Thune and Mitch McConnell blocked Donald Trump's legislative agenda.Sources support that Thune blocked Trump's SAVE America Act by refusing to end the filibuster, but they contradict the broader claim that he blocked the president's legislative agenda, since the Senate under Thune passed much of it. No source shows McConnell, who is no longer majority leader and was largely absent, blocking Trump's agenda in 2026. The post's claim is that Thune blocked Trump and that McConnell did too; the extraction's wording matches that.6 sources →

    ▶ 5:06

  10. 10TrueNon-citizens are voting in United States elections and are being arrested and indicted for it.Official Justice Department records show federal indictments and arrests of noncitizens accused of illegally voting in the 2024 election and of registering fraudulently, so the core assertion that non-citizens are voting and being arrested and indicted for it is supported as of 2026-10-26. Reuters describes the problem as rare and says it has not been shown to change outcomes, which is context rather than contradiction; the claim does not assert scale, and the post's 'illegals' label is the poster's own wording.3 sources →

    ▶ 5:51

  11. 11Can’t tellDemocrats allow illegal immigrants to vote in elections.The claim departs from the passage: the post says non-citizens are voting and that arrests are being made, but it never says Democrats allow this, and its only political attribution is to Republican leaders such as Thune and the president. Fact-checkers do reject the broader allegation that Democrats deliberately let illegal immigrants vote, but that is not the post's assertion, so the verdict is unverifiable.4 sources →

    ▶ 5:51

  12. 12FalseDonald Trump has settled eight different wars during his second term.The claim that Trump settled eight wars during his second term is contradicted by multiple fact-checkers (AP, Snopes, CNN, Reuters-style FACT FOCUS) who found the figure highly exaggerated: at least two listed 'wars' (Egypt-Ethiopia dam dispute, Serbia-Kosovo) were never wars, and others such as Rwanda-Congo and Cambodia-Thailand saw fresh fighting. The extraction faithfully reflects the post's 'settling eight different wars, which is nice'; the post's own rhetorical framing is the claimant's, and the fact-checkers' dismissal is the decisive independent record.5 sources →

    ▶ 6:40

  13. 13FalseThe 2020 presidential election was stolen from Donald Trump.The claim that the 2020 presidential election was stolen from Trump is contradicted by multiple authoritative sources, including AP, FactCheck.org, Reuters, and PolitiFact, which found no evidence of fraud that could have changed the outcome. The claim is a faithful extraction of the post's assertion, so the verdict grades it directly.7 sources →

    ▶ 8:03

  14. 14FalseThe Biden administration brought 15 to 20 million illegal aliens into the United States.The claim that Biden brought in 15 to 20 million illegal aliens is not supported by the sources. The best available measures show roughly 7 to 11 million border encounters (which count events, not unique entries) and a population increase of about 4 to 10 million, both well short of 15 to 20 million.5 sources →

    ▶ 8:16

  15. 15FalseThere are 30 to 40 million illegal aliens in the United States.As of 2026-10-26, the sources' current estimates put the illegal alien population far below 30 to 40 million: about 13.5 million (CIS, July 2026), 15.8 million (MPI, mid-2024), and 18.6 million (FAIR, March 2025), with PolitiFact noting that the highest research estimate it found was 16.8 million. The claim's figure is roughly double the highest estimate, and the sources explicitly reject much higher numbers. The one range that could be read as reaching that level, DHS's 11-22 million pre-crisis population plus at least 10 million entrants in a congressional letter, is a sum of older, unreconciled figures rather than a current estimate.7 sources →

    ▶ 8:25

  16. 16TrueAn individual entered the United States from Mexico in December 1999 and was granted DACA status.Multiple reports citing federal sources say the Quantico Iwo Jima statue suspect, Miguel Alonso Maldonado Soriano, illegally entered the U.S. in December 1999 and was granted DACA, which later lapsed. All of this traces back to one Fox News report based on anonymous federal sources, so confidence is moderate.6 sources →

    ▶ 12:03

  17. 17FalseDonald Trump ended DACA earlier in 2026.The claim that Trump ended DACA earlier in 2026 is contradicted by the sources, which describe the program as still in effect despite administration efforts to undermine it. Reporting describes renewal delays, halted approvals for new applicants, and enforcement against recipients, but no formal termination. The claim is a faithful extraction of the post's 'Trump ended, thankfully, DACA earlier this year.'6 sources →

    ▶ 12:23

  18. 18TrueA memorial at Quantico Marine Base was vandalized with a sledgehammer, resulting in the decapitation of a sculpture.Multiple sources, including police-based reporting and a DHS release, confirm that a man struck the Iwo Jima memorial at Marine Corps Base Quantico in Virginia with a sledgehammer and decapitated one of the statue's figures. The suspect has been charged, and the sources describe the attack as alleged pending court proceedings. The extracted claim matches the passage's core assertion; the post's broader details about the DACA status and the policy argument are not part of the graded claim.6 sources →

    ▶ 12:51

  19. 19TrueThe individual who vandalized the Iwo Jima memorial is an illegal alien from Mexico who has been on the dole for 26 years.Multiple authoritative sources (DHS, DOJ, Fox News, NY Post) confirm the Iwo Jima Memorial vandal, Miguel Alonso Maldonado Soriano, is a Mexican illegal alien, and the post's "26 years" roughly matches his reported 1999 entry. No source addresses the claim that he has been "on the dole" for 26 years, and none contradicts it; that unconfirmed welfare detail comes only from the claimant's own words.5 sources →

    ▶ 18:29

  20. 20Can’t tellThe individual who vandalized the Iwo Jima memorial received $2,000 a month in cash via an EBT card.No provided source mentions EBT cards, cash benefits, or any government payments to Miguel Alonso Maldonado Soriano, so the claim cannot be graded either way. The claim also departs from the passage: the post presents the $2,000 figure as a speculative bet ('I bet you'), not as a verified fact, and the extraction drops that framing.7 sources →

    ▶ 19:00

  21. 21TrueThe Iwo Jima memorial was damaged by a person using a sledgehammer to decapitate one of the soldiers.Multiple outlets citing the Prince William County Police Department report that Miguel Alonso Maldonado Soriano used a sledgehammer on the Iwo Jima statue at Marine Corps Base Quantico on Oct. 21, 2026, knocking off one soldier's head. The man has been charged and is presumed innocent, and the statue is a replica at Quantico rather than the Arlington memorial, but the core assertion is supported.7 sources →

    ▶ 21:48

  22. 22Can’t tellNikki Haley oversaw the removal of statues while she was governor.The sources document Haley's role in removing the Confederate battle flag from the South Carolina Statehouse in 2015, but none reports statues being taken down while she was governor. The claim also departs from the passage, which says statues were taken down and does not say Haley oversaw it, so the sources neither confirm nor refute the claim.7 sources →

    ▶ 25:19

  23. 23Can’t tellDonald Trump has removed Communists from the United States.The extracted claim says Trump removed Communists from the United States, but the post only said Communists should be gotten out of "our backyard" and that he had done that, which is a foreign-policy reference, not a claim about removing people from the US. None of the sources reports any removal of Communists from the US; they cover Trump's anti-communist rhetoric and a 2023 proposal to bar Communists from entry, so the central assertion is neither supported nor contradicted.7 sources →

    ▶ 27:12

  24. 24TrueDonald Trump and Mike Johnson claim that polling for the November 3 election is incorrect.Johnson's public statements that the polls are wrong are documented by AP and Reuters before the 2026-10-26 post date, and a New York Times-Siena-based report says Trump and Johnson both disputed the polls. Trump's own rejection of polling rests mainly on unrated secondhand reports, so that half of the claim is less directly sourced.8 sources →

    ▶ 28:09

  25. 25TrueThe party out of power historically picks up seats in midterm elections.Multiple sources, including Reuters, AP, Britannica and Al Jazeera, show that midterms typically cost the president's party seats, which means the out-of-power party usually gains. The claim's dropped word "always" makes it a historical generalization, and sources note the trend is weaker in the Senate, where out-of-power gains are less consistent.8 sources →

    ▶ 28:37

  26. 26TruePollsters have fraudulently given false polls in past elections.Multiple sources report that at least two polling firms, Wedgewood Polls and Median Strategies, admitted fabricating poll results in the 2026 cycle, which supports the claim that pollsters have fraudulently given false polls. The sources describe a small number of fraudulent firms rather than pollsters as a whole, and the polls concerned were the 2026 midterm-cycle polls rather than older elections.4 sources →

    ▶ 31:02

  27. 27Can’t tellA Red-Green Alliance exists within the Democratic Party in the United States.The claim that a Red-Green Alliance exists within the Democratic Party is a sweeping characterization of a political faction, and the sources are almost entirely opinion pieces, advocacy commentary, and claims by Cruz, Gaffney, and others that echo the framing without independent factual record; no fact-checker or authoritative body examined and rejected or confirmed it. The post's own assertion is also hyperbolic rhetoric about 'the rise' of an alliance across many countries, which the sources do not substantiate or dismiss as a checkable fact.10 sources →

    ▶ 32:00

  28. 28FalseThe Democratic Party in the United States has formed an alliance between communists, socialists, and Islamists.The claim that the Democratic Party has formed an alliance with communists, socialists and Islamists repeats a broad allegation that AP and PolitiFact fact-checks, dated July 2026, found inaccurate. The sources show only a small DSA-aligned faction, no openly communist candidate ever elected, and most Democratic candidates not running as socialists; none document a party-level alliance with Islamists, and the claim as posted (October 26) is not contradicted by any later development.12 sources →

    ▶ 32:18

  29. 29OpinionThe Democratic Party is an alliance of communists, socialists and Islamists that hates Jews, Christians, whites and Western civilization.A judgement, not a statement of fact. It has no true or false answer.

    ▶ 32:19

  30. 30TrueStatues and memorials were desecrated during Black Lives Matter and Antifa riots.Multiple sources, including a Reuters investigation and a Stanford-style scholarly article, document statues and memorials being torn down or defaced during the 2020 George Floyd/Black Lives Matter protests, with Antifa participation reported in some incidents (e.g., Portland statue toppling). The claim's core assertion that statues and memorials were desecrated during these riots is supported, though the sources also note limited evidence of a central Antifa role, which bears on the Antifa attribution.6 sources →

    ▶ 37:23

  31. 31FalseIn the Middle East, desecrating a memorial or testament to Islam or a holy warrior results in punishments such as having a hand cut off, torture, or 20 to 25 years in jail.The sources do not support the claimed Middle East penalties of hand amputation, torture, or 20 to 25 years for desecrating Islamic memorials. The Middle Eastern desecration and blasphemy laws they cover (Algeria, UAE) set far lower prison terms, such as 3 months to 3 years for grave destruction in Algeria, while the only 30-year penalty found is Brunei's, which is not in the Middle East. The claim also departs from the passage's wording on scope, since the sources concern graves and places of worship rather than memorials to 'holy warriors'.3 sources →

    ▶ 38:47

  32. 32TrueDonald Trump is aware of the memorial vandalism incident and is angry about it.Sources show Trump repeatedly and angrily commented on memorial vandalism, including the August 2026 WWII Memorial spray-painting and the Reflecting Pool damage he kept blaming on vandals as of October 2026, so awareness and anger are supported as of 2026-10-26. The post does not name which incident it means; the WWII Memorial case is the likeliest referent, and the sources do not address the deportation or prosecution details the speaker predicted.7 sources →

    ▶ 39:50

  33. 33Can’t tellDonald Trump has expressed anger regarding a specific individual who vandalized a memorial.Sources show Trump repeatedly expressed anger at vandals of the WWII Memorial and the Reflecting Pool, calling them "animals" and saying "we are on their trail," but his statements targeted unidentified vandals or the handling of the case, not a specific individual. The post's "this guy" is not clearly identified in the sources, and none ties Trump's anger to a named person as of 2026-10-26, so the claim is not clearly graded either way.9 sources →

    ▶ 39:50

  34. 34PredictionDonald Trump will make a point to ICE and the Department of Homeland Security to get the Iwo Jima vandal deported, and the vandal will be prosecuted and face some jail time.Can't be checked yet.

    ▶ 40:04

  35. 35Can’t tellThe caller's father served as a sergeant major in the Marine Corps for 24 years.None of the sources mention the caller's father, a Marine Corps sergeant major with 24 years of service. The only evidence of that service is the caller's own statement in the passage, which cannot corroborate the claim, and the other sources concern unrelated Marines or Tim Walz.10 sources →

    ▶ 40:44

  36. 36Can’t tellThe caller's father was stationed at Quantico.The claim faithfully restates the caller's own words that his father was stationed in Quantico, but none of the provided sources mention the caller's father or his service history. The sources only describe Quantico as a Marine Corps base, so the personal claim can be neither confirmed nor refuted.2 sources →

    ▶ 40:57

  37. 37Can’t tellThe caller was born in Newport, Rhode Island.None of the provided sources addresses the speaker's birthplace. The passage is a caller's own statement, and the sources are generic Newport records, obituaries, and unrelated pages that cannot be tied to this person. The claim's 'caller' is also loosely resolved: the speaker thanks 'the caller, Mark' as a separate person, so the speaker is a different caller, which the claim does not make clear.4 sources →

    ▶ 41:49

  38. 38Can’t tellJerry Calabay was a professor at McGill University.None of the provided sources mention Jerry Calabay or any McGill professor by that name; the only support is the claimant's own passage, which cannot corroborate the claim. The claim matches the passage faithfully, so the verdict rests on absence of coverage rather than contradiction.8 sources →

    ▶ 42:55

  39. 39TrueThe National Symphony Orchestra is performing Tchaikovsky's The Nutcracker and Prokofiev's Cinderella on November 20, 2026, at Rachel Schlesinger Hall and November 21-22, 2026, at Lisner Auditorium.The sources show the NSO's Nutcracker & Cinderella program on Nov. 20, 2026 at Rachel M. Schlesinger Concert Hall and on Nov. 21 and 22, 2026 at Lisner Auditorium, matching the claim. The listings were published on 2026-10-30 and 2026-10-31, after the 2026-10-26 post date, but they describe the schedule as announced in August, so they reflect the state of affairs on the post date.7 sources →

    ▶ 45:59

  40. 40FalseViolent communist Islamist insurrectionists are targeting symbols in France, Italy, Spain, Portugal, and Belgium to show contempt for those countries.The claim that violent communist Islamist insurrectionists deliberately target national symbols to show contempt is not supported. AP's fact check (Oct 20, 2026) found that no group had been singled out for the French riots and that authorities had not linked immigrants to the rioting, and the sources that name Islamist or communist actors are opinion or low-credibility pieces that do not address deliberate symbol-targeting. The extraction is faithful to the passage, and the claim was made on 2026-10-26, before the later Reuters coverage of the Trappes shooting, which is unrelated.9 sources →

    ▶ 16:32

  41. 41TrueCharlie Kirk was murdered.Multiple tier1 sources report that Charlie Kirk was shot and killed at a Utah Valley University event on September 10, 2025, and Utah's governor called it a 'political assassination,' so the claim that he was murdered is supported as of the posting date. The sources describe a killing by gunshot and an assassination rather than using the legal term 'murder,' and the post itself said 'killed,' so the wording is a fair paraphrase.7 sources →

    ▶ 26:21

  42. 42TrueDonald Trump attempted to acquire Greenland.Multiple tier1 and tier2 sources (AP, Reuters, NYT, Stanford, CNN, Snopes) document Trump's sustained push to acquire Greenland from Denmark, including a 2019 purchase proposal, 2025 military/economic threats, and an inside-look campaign described in his own term; the claim's core assertion that he attempted to acquire Greenland is well supported, and the extraction faithfully reflects the passage's 'we needed Greenland' framing.6 sources →

    ▶ 27:36

Sources

Fact-checkers 53Primary records 17Most reliable outlets 5Reliable outlets 15Less reliable outlets 3Unrated 136Rated low 2

  • gatestoneinstitute.orgRated low for factual reporting by Iffy.news · cited in checking claim 40
  • lewrockwell.comRated low for factual reporting by Iffy.news and Media Bias/Fact Check · cited in checking claim 40

How Polygraph reads a postHow often are we wrong?

Our Weekly Newsletter

The Readout

The week's most-shared posts, checked. What they claimed, how they argued, and what held up.

Unsubscribe any time. See our privacy policy.