Achilles for Idaho | U.S. Senate 2026 on Senator Jim Risch's voting record on the Iran war and his campaign position
Achilles for Idaho | U.S. Senate 2026, Checked
Polygraph score77Holds upDetailsHide
77Holds up
- What it claims
- 1 mixed3 can’t tell4 true
- How it argues
- Nothing found
- How it persuades
- Name-calling
- What it’s built on
- Nothing found
Achilles for Idaho | U.S. Senate 2026@Achilles4IdahoOct 11, 2026
I have been calling on Jim Risch to end this Iran War from the beginning. Now Jim Risch is "changing his mind," conveniently while he's trying to get your vote. You can't trust a coward like Jim. Vote November 3rd. https://www.spokesman.com/stories/2026/oct/10/jim-risch-calls-for-iran-war-to-end-as-rising-cost/
What it claims
Claims
- 1TrueJim Risch is 83 years old.Jim Risch was born May 3, 1943 according to the official Congressional Biographical Directory, which makes him 83 on 2026-10-12. LegiStorm lists his age as 83 and Ballotpedia's September 2026 coverage also calls him 83. The extracted claim drops the passage's 2022 vote reference but correctly states his current age, and one unrated Facebook post saying 82 is older and does not outweigh the birth-date record.6 sources →
- 2TrueJim Risch is the chair of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee.The Senate Foreign Relations Committee's official site (primary) lists James E. Risch as Chairman, and Senator Risch's official biography (primary) states he serves as Chairman of the committee, so the claim is supported as of 2026-10-12. Less authoritative unrated sources (Wikipedia, Ballotpedia) show older chair listings, and the Wikipedia entry is outdated, but they do not contradict the primary records for the claim's date.4 sources →
- 3Can’t tellJim Risch voted 14 times to keep the Iran war going.Source 2 says Risch has voted repeatedly against measures to end the Iran war, which supports the general direction of the claim. No source gives the figure of 14 votes, and none contradicts it, so the specific count cannot be verified. The extracted claim matches the claimant's passage, which also says 14 votes.3 sources →
- 4Mixed21 American soldiers have died in the Iran war.As of 2026-10-11, the official Pentagon casualty count listed 21 U.S. service members killed in the Iran war, as reported by multiple tier1/tier2 outlets, so the claim holds under the official measure. However, the Washington Post reported at least 22 deaths (Sept. 18) and independent estimates on Wikipedia list 26, so the figure fails under an independent count. The extracted claim faithfully matches the passage's figure of 21.9 sources →
- 5Can’t tellMore than 850 American soldiers have been permanently injured in the Iran war.The claim's figure of more than 850 is close to the Pentagon's reported wounded total (865 as of Oct 10, 2026, per sources [3] and [9]), but every source counts all wounded troops, not those permanently injured. No source reports a permanent-injury count, so the central 'permanently injured' assertion is not addressed. The extracted claim matches the passage's wording, and the sources are consistent with the 850+ figure as of 2026-10-11 for wounded, not permanent injuries.5 sources →
- 6TrueThe U.S. military blew up a girl's school in the Iran war.Multiple tier1 and tier2 sources support the claim that a U.S. strike destroyed a girls' school in Iran's war, the Feb. 28 Minab school strike. Fact-checkers and a UN mission attribute the strike to the U.S. with 'likely' or 'reasonable grounds' wording rather than formal admission, and the claim's extraction from the speaker's 'we blew up a girl's school' is a fair paraphrase.7 sources →
- 7TrueTodd Achilles served in the Persian Gulf as a tank commander.Multiple sources state that Todd Achilles served in the U.S. Army as a tank commander and deployed twice to the Persian Gulf, so the claim is supported as extracted. The claimant's own passage was used only to resolve the referent and was not treated as evidence; the sources also do not give a specific deployment date, which is a peripheral detail.6 sources →
- 8Can’t tellThere are 5,000 Idahoans on active duty.None of the sources gives a total for Idahoans on active duty as of 2026-10-11. The only Idaho-specific headcount, about 3,000 Idaho National Guard soldiers, measures a different component, so it neither confirms nor refutes the 5,000 figure. The extracted claim matches the passage's figure and scope, so no extraction drift needs correcting.6 sources →
How it persuades
- Name-callingA label stands in for the argument
coward
liar
Rubber stamp